Originally Posted by
Hal...
You seem to be forgetting that Lewis is one of the best two or three passers for the last decade or more. (I agree about the Russell pit last year)
I think RB should have pitted Max the same lap or the lap after Merc pitted Lewis. Lewis would probably have undercut Max in the second scenario but RB would then have two options. IIRC, Max was on mediums after the second stop so, for option A, he could have just bided his time, saving his tires, and built up a gap greater than the pit delta once Lewis pitted. Or, w/option B, Max could have easily stayed within striking distance of Lewis, matching his lap times and saving his tires in the process, pulling within a second or two toward the end of his stint, and then pitting a few laps before the expected tire deg forced Lewis to pit, thereby undercutting him. The danger then becomes Lewis staying out on a one pit strategy. But by the end of the race, Lewis' tires would be absolute shit and Max should have had no problem passing him.
As for the first scenario, it would force RB to react to Merc, letting the latter dictate the race, yes, but I could see three things happening: (1) Max keeps his lead; (2) Lewis takes the lead and we're back to the two options mentioned before; or (3) Merc pulls a fast one and opts to keep Lewis out. In situation (3), RB now gets to dictate the race because they have effectively undercut Merc since Lewis would still have to pit.
I hope you followed all that. Sorry for not laying it out more clearly.
And then, of course, is what Martin Brundle said: that Max didn't have to give the position back immediately and should have waited for a more opportune time.
But I can't believe we're still talking about this. When they first implemented the required tire change rule, I recognized very early on that whoever pits first almost always has the advantage. Ferrari has shown time and time again how disregarding that has left them in second or third place.
And Merc has shown time and time again that they're almost always the best at strategy. As for RB, I cannot recall a time in the past seven seasons they won a race on strategy the few times when the cars were more evenly matched.
You know, I should email Christian Horner. lol
Bookmarks